Recent reports of COVID-19-associated myocarditis have raised safety concerns for athletes returning to training after recovering from COVID-19. As a result, our institution initiated a comprehensive screening program for all student athletes recovering from COVID-19, to screen for myocarditis using non-invasive diagnostic tests, including cardiac MRI. In this retrospective study we describe our institutional experience, including the prevalence and severity of MRI findings of myocarditis in student athletes recovering from COVID-19. Patients had mild (73/149;49%) or moderate symptoms (40/149;27%), or were asymptomatic (26/149;17%). Only 2/149 patients had MRI findings consistent with updated Lake Louise criteria for myocarditis (1.3%, 95%CI 0.4%,4.8%).